Help

Categories



Still Need Help?

Contact Us

Searching for Magic: The Gathering singles, sealed products or supplies? Please try searching our Star City Games online store.

Our Buylist

Search

You can search using the Product Name drop-down for a specific card or search By Set to pull up an entire set at once. Your search can be further refined by rarity, foiling and set using the available filters at the top of the displayed results. Once an item has been added to your cart, a reminder pop-up will appear to confirm the last submission.

If the English version of a card is not being purchased at this time, our Buylist will default to the next available language. Please ensure that the correct language is displayed before adding your item to the cart.

We do not appraise collections for insurance purposes.

We do not authenticate cards. Please contact Wizards of the Coast Customer Service if you feel you are in possession of a counterfeit card.

If you have a complete set you would like to sell, please email buyer@starcitygames.com in order to get interest and pricing. Complete sets are considered based on Near Mint condition with each card present within a set. If cards are missing or are not in Near Mint condition, the offer will be reduced.

Notice about Heavily Played cards: Due to the large amount potential damage that our Heavily Played section covers, offers on each Heavily Played card will be made in isolation and may be lower than our listed buylist price. While this is not always the case, customers should note that the listed buylist price reflects the highest possible offer on Heavily Played cards.

Prices for Sealed Product and Supplies can be found using their specific search sections.

The cart summary at the top of the page can be referenced at any time to see the current subtotal and number of items. Select View Cart at the top right of the Buylist page to bring up your Sell Cart.

Pricing

The Specific Prices search tool in our Buylist provides you with the prices we’re currently paying for individual items based on a number of factors, including but not limited to current and pending supply and condition. If your search for a specific card does not yield a result, we are currently purchasing that card only at Bulk Price in English (we do not purchase non-English bulk). Bulk Commons, Uncommons, and Basic Lands are purchased only in lots of 1,000.

Because Specific Prices are language-specific, be sure to select the correct language from the drop-down menu in the card listing. Buy prices for specific foil non-English cards are available upon request. 

Sealed Product

Sealed product may not be preordered with store credit or purchased with store credit until the Monday after the product's release. 

Stores and Vendors

If you’re closing your store or have decided to no longer stock Magic: The Gathering singles, contact us. Unlike many dealers, we’ll make you an offer for anything related to Magic: The Gathering, even the excess commons taking up space in your back room! 

To sell bulk Magic: The Gathering singles of any type and/or quantity, please contact us. Please be sure to identify yourself as a store and/or vendor. Failing to do so may result in our declining to purchase from you now or in the future.